Skip to main content
ChapterBriefChapterBrief

Copycat Review: 7.8/10, Carnby Kim's New Horror Thriller

The Sweet Home team drops the monsters and builds a thriller about a failed artist who wants credit for a killer's work.

VerdictWorth starting now if you liked Bastard more than Sweet Home. The hook is the best the pair have had, but the mystery hasn't paid off yet, so it scores 7.8.

Updated Published 6 min readBy Ethan MercerLast reviewed

Copycat is worth starting now, and this Copycat review gives it 7.8 out of 10. Carnby Kim and Youngchan Hwang, the pair behind Bastard and Sweet Home, have built their sharpest premise yet: a serial killer is selling corpses as art, and the one man who recognizes the idea is the failed artist who came up with it. The score stays under 8 for one reason. The series is still early, and a mystery this good-looking can still fumble its answer.

Crop of the Copycat cover: one face split down the middle, the left half dark-haired with blood running from the eye, the right half pale and drawn in rough sketch lines, on a red background

Reviewing

Copycat

Carnby Kim (story), Youngchan Hwang (art) · WEBTOON

7.8

Score

7.8/ 10
WEBTOON

Pros

  • A hook nobody else has: the hero's grievance is that a serial killer stole his idea
  • Carnby Kim and Youngchan Hwang, the pair behind Bastard and Sweet Home
  • A cover that sells the theme: one face, half finished, half sketch
  • No monsters or powers, so it reads closer to Bastard than to Sweet Home

Cons

  • Still early: the mystery hasn't paid off, and there's no end date
  • A lead built on envy and wounded pride is hard to root for
  • Weekly releases and a mature gate, with the newest episodes held back for the app

How we score manhwa and anime

What Copycat is about

Korean cover of Copycat under its original title 표절의혹: a young man's face split down the middle, dark-haired and bloodied on the left, pale and sketched on the right, with the title in large white letters Copycat's Korean cover, titled 표절의혹 (image via AniList).

WEBTOON's summary sets it up in two lines: "A serial killer is staging corpses as 'self-destruction art' and selling them to the ultra-wealthy for tens of millions." When failed artist Suchan Kim recognizes the concept as his own, "stolen from an exhibition the world laughed into oblivion," his need to prove it "mutates into something darker: a hunger for the recognition he never received."

Advertisement

That's the whole engine, and it's a mean one. Most thrillers give you a lead who wants the killer stopped. Suchan wants the credit. The Korean title, 표절의혹, means roughly "plagiarism suspicion," which tells you where the horror sits: in authorship and envy as much as in the bodies.

Who made it, and why that matters

Kim writes and Hwang draws, the same split as Bastard (2014 to 2017) and Sweet Home (2017 to 2020). Bastard was a serial killer story told from inside the killer's house, and Sweet Home was a monster apocalypse. Copycat is much closer to the first. There are no monsters or powers so far. On r/manhwa, a reader answering whether it ties into their other series said "there are no supernatural elements as of now. it more of a thriller , mystery with mature dark theme" (comment).

The pairing is a selling point on its own. When the English release was announced, one reader joked that "This youngchan hwang guy is pretty loyal to carnby ngl," and the most upvoted comment in that thread ranked the old work bluntly: "Sweet home was good, Bastard was legendary." If you agree with that ranking, Copycat is aimed at you.

How it reads

WEBTOON's English poster for Copycat: the same split face in front of a dim studio with a plaster bust on the left and a shadowed figure on the right WEBTOON's English poster for Copycat (image via WEBTOON).

The art does the theme's work. The cover face is half finished and half sketch, and the English poster puts it in a studio next to a plaster bust, so the series looks like a question about who made what before you read a line. Readers who've started it describe the tone the same way. When someone in the first thread asked whether it's "good or just slop," the same reader called it "great stuff if you like dark and mature theme" and, pressed on what kind of dark, added that "there is some gore and it shows of theme of trauma , human emotions out of control and overall it have a eerie vibe to it."

The risk is the lead. A hero driven by wounded pride is interesting for a while and exhausting if he never changes, and the series hasn't shown yet which way Suchan goes. That's the main reason for the score.

Where to read it, and the catch

DetailStatus
Korean startJanuary 6, 2026 (Naver Webtoon)
English startApril 14, 2026 (WEBTOON, Prologue plus Episodes 1 and 2)
Latest English episodeEpisode 28, October 13, 2026
ScheduleWeekly, listed under Wednesday
AccessMature gate; WEBTOON says "Read 11 new episodes only on the app!"

The English launch was smaller than earlier versions of this review said: three installments on day one, not ten. It has been weekly since. WEBTOON marks Copycat as a mature title and asks you to confirm before viewing, and the newest episodes sit in the app ahead of the website. Our Copycat reading guide tracks the episode count.

Copycat review: verdict

The Good

  • A hook nobody else has: the hero's grievance is that a serial killer stole his idea
  • Carnby Kim and Youngchan Hwang, the pair behind Bastard and Sweet Home
  • A cover that sells the theme: one face, half finished, half sketch
  • No monsters or powers, so it reads closer to Bastard than to Sweet Home

The Cons

  • Still early: the mystery hasn't paid off, and there's no end date
  • A lead built on envy and wounded pride is hard to root for
  • Weekly releases and a mature gate, with the newest episodes held back for the app

Our take

Advertisement

The short Copycat review: start it if Bastard is your favorite of their books; wait a few months if you want to binge. The premise is strong enough to carry the series without the creators' names, and the names are earned. What we can't tell you yet is whether the answer to "who stole from whom" will be as good as the question. Until it is, 7.8.

Rating: 7.8/10

How we checked this

For this update we read WEBTOON's Copycat list pages (all three pages, fetched October 15, 2026), AniList's entries for Copycat, Bastard and Sweet Home and its credit list for Youngchan Hwang, and two r/manhwa threads through the Arctic Shift archive. We didn't reread the series; the description comes from WEBTOON's summary and the readers quoted above. This pass fixed the English launch (three installments on April 14, 2026, not ten chapters), Bastard's end year (2017) and the episode count (28, not 26). It removed Sweet Home view and Netflix ranking figures we couldn't source, the claims about "immediate and loud" reaction, the TL;DR, the key takeaways and the FAQ.

Last reviewed: October 15, 2026

References

Tagscopycatcarnby-kimhorror-thrillerwebtoon

About the author

Ethan Mercer

Manhwa: progression and system fantasy

ChapterBrief byline for action, isekai and system-fantasy manhwa. Picks come from the opening chapters of the official release, and every status and chapter count is checked against the platform page and AniList.

  • Reads the opening chapters of the official release
  • Facts traced to a sources table
  • Opinions marked as ours

Disclaimer

This article is published for informational and entertainment purposes. It does not constitute professional financial, legal, or technical advice. Series availability, platform access, translation status, and chapter counts change. Verify critical details (pricing, regional availability, official translation status) with publishers and platforms. Affiliate links, where present, help support our editorial work and are labelled in our affiliate disclosure.